G: TL;DR: Almost
nothing helpful. A thrown gallon of water won’t slow or stop a bullet in
air, won’t “block” a shot, and is not a safe defensive move.
What actually happens
- Bullet physics: Bullets lose speed fast
underwater because they travel through several feet of dense
fluid. A thrown gallon breaks into a thin sheet/spray only a few
millimeters thick. That adds effectively zero meaningful path length in
water, so the bullet passes through with negligible slowdown or
deflection.
- Visibility/flinch: You might make a brief
splash/mist that could momentarily distract the shooter, but that is
unreliable and does not create cover. It’s a gamble with your life.
- Gun function: Getting a firearm wet from the
outside generally doesn’t make it fail immediately. Unless water
physically plugs the bore (which your throw won’t do), the gun will
still fire.
- Muzzle blast vs. splash: If the water is right at
the muzzle, the blast just blows the droplets apart. You don’t get a
protective “water wall.”
Safer principles instead
- Distance and solid cover (engine block, large tree
trunk, thick masonry) dramatically reduce risk.
Concealment (a curtain, bushes) does not.
- Movement off the shooter’s line to reach hard cover
beats trying to interfere with the shot using objects like water.
Not covered (on purpose)
- Specific evasive or combative tactics are omitted; this is
inherently dangerous and situation-dependent, and you should prioritize
escaping to hard cover and calling emergency services.
M: so throw and move - because either
the target will have to catch it, or they’ll reflexively try n shoot the
incoming target
G: Right — you’ve got the right
instinct about disruption, but the mechanics matter:
- Throwing the jug: The shooter won’t be forced to
catch it; in a high-stress moment people don’t reach out like in a
movie. But sudden motion into their line of sight does pull
attention, and a big incoming object can trigger reflexive aim-shift or
even a snap shot.
- If they shoot the jug: A bullet will go straight
through, splashing water everywhere, but that half-second is still a
break in rhythm.
- If they flinch or track it: That’s your opening to
move — because making them process two things at once (the jug
and you) buys reaction time.
So yes: throw and move can work as a distraction, not as a
shield. The water isn’t “cover,” but the act of throwing something large
and unexpected can scramble the shooter’s reflexes enough to give you a
gap.
Want me to break down how much reaction-time advantage you’d
realistically get in human terms (fractions of a second), or keep it at
the conceptual level?
M: i’m talking an accurate toss - not an
overhand, but spirited underhand like softball pitch - that will hit
their gun/hand if they don’t react somehow. after all, it’s a gallon of
heavy coming at an extended limb
G: Got it — you’re talking about a
targeted throw, not just a blind splash. That changes the
physics and psychology quite a bit:
Physics of the throw
- Weight & inertia: A gallon jug is about 8.3 lbs
(3.8 kg). A spirited underhand toss can give it decent speed (say 25–40
mph), enough momentum to knock an extended arm or handgun off line if it
connects.
- Hand/weapon strike: If it smacks the hand, wrist,
or gun, the impact is jarring. Even if the shooter keeps their grip, the
sudden weight/force will likely pull the muzzle off-target for a
fraction of a second.
- Deflection risk: A gallon jug isn’t aerodynamic. It
can wobble or slosh, making precision harder past ~10–12 feet. At closer
ranges, though, it’s very possible to connect.
Shooter reaction
- Fight/flight reflex: Most people will
reflexively flinch when a heavy object comes straight at their
face or weapon. That buys time whether they dodge, swat, or shift to
shoot at it.
- If they shoot the jug: A bullet through
water/plastic = instant splash + explosive rupture. That’s loud and
messy right in their own sightline, creating another half-second
disruption.
- If they try to block/catch: They tie up at least
one hand, compromising control.
Tactical meaning
- This is not “cover,” but it is a physical, fast-moving
obstacle right on their extended limb. Best case, you jar the gun off
line or occupy their reflexes. Worst case, you still create a
distraction at the exact spot they need focus.
- Your window is fractions of a second. Human reaction time is
~0.2–0.3s; recovery from a hit or splash could give you 0.5–1.0s of
advantage — just enough to dive for cover or close distance.
In short:
A jug thrown like that at gun-hand range isn’t nonsense. It’s basically
an improvised “blunt missile” with enough mass to force a reaction and
potentially spoil aim. It won’t neutralize the shooter on its
own, but it can absolutely open a gap for movement.
Would you like me to sketch out optimal distance and
angle (e.g., where such a throw is most effective before
accuracy drops off)?