M: Do you know Pokémon go?

G: Yes, I’m familiar with Pokémon GO. It’s an augmented reality mobile game where players explore the real world to catch Pokémon, battle in gyms, complete raids, and participate in various events. Are you looking for tips, event updates, or something else?

M: I’m trying to build some kind of system in which, given a list of the Pokémon moves and the statistics related to them, I can contrast and compare the statistics of multiple move combinations, selectively. I can do it slowly in a manual method with what I know of spreadsheets using libre office Calc, and I know enough programming that if it were a larger project, I could simply write a Python program. Answer briefly. Can I do this in a spreadsheet, or do I need to shift to a database? And either way, can you please give me a broad strokes breakdown of what I need to do to accomplish this task?

G: You can accomplish this in a spreadsheet if the dataset is relatively small and manageable. A database is better if you expect the data to grow significantly or require complex querying.

Broad Strokes Breakdown:

Spreadsheet Approach:

  1. Data Organization: Create columns for move names, stats (damage, energy cost, etc.), and combinations.
  2. Formulas: Use functions like SUM, AVERAGE, IF, and VLOOKUP to compare and analyze stats.
  3. Filters/Conditional Formatting: Highlight key combinations and make filtering easier.
  4. Pivot Tables: Summarize and compare statistics dynamically.

Database Approach:

  1. Set Up Database: Use SQLite or a similar lightweight option.
  2. Define Tables: Create tables for moves, stats, and combinations with relationships.
  3. Query with SQL: Write queries to compare stats (e.g., SELECT SUM(damage) FROM moves WHERE...).
  4. Interface: Optionally, connect the database to a Python script or use a GUI tool like DB Browser.

A spreadsheet is sufficient for small-scale analysis, but a database is better for scalability and advanced querying.

M: Let’s say from two tables - “Fast” and “Charge” - of about 100 elements, I want to pull 3-6 entries from each, then perform calculations on each combination of Fast and Charge and display the results. There will be minimal change in the data after the initial creation. Please summarize the pros and cons of each approach, spreadsheet and database.

G:

Spreadsheet

Pros:

Cons:


Database

Pros:

Cons:


For your scenario, spreadsheets are simpler and sufficient, but if you anticipate scaling up or require frequent, complex analysis, consider a database.

M: Let’s go with spreadsheet. Assume I have the data entered: two simple tables on separate sheets in Libre office. How do I go from this data to the previously stated goal being able to select multiple entries from each, perform calculations, and return a readable table showing the resultant calculations of each combination? I apologize for the vagueness, but: please attempt to be as detailed as possible, without being overly verbose.

G: Here’s a clear, step-by-step process for achieving your goal in LibreOffice Calc:


1. Structure Your Data


2. Create a Selection Area


3. Extract Selected Moves


4. Generate Combinations


5. Perform Calculations


6. Display Results


7. Automate Updates


This approach leverages basic spreadsheet functions while keeping it maintainable. For a more dynamic experience, you could consider using macros, but they aren't strictly necessary for your stated goal.

M: If necessary, please modify (if necessary, I haven’t looked into it yet) number four to account for the fact that the exact number of necessary fast and charge moves for each analysis is variable from test to test. The point is to automate as much as possible; having to rebuild the helper tables for each quantity is the kind of automation needed.

G: To handle variable numbers of selected moves and automate the creation of the helper table in step 4, here’s an improved approach:


4. Generate Combinations Dynamically

Dynamic Fast and Charge Selection

  1. Use named ranges or dynamic arrays:

    • Extract selected moves from the "Selections" sheet into dynamic lists using FILTER or conditional logic (e.g., only pull rows where the selection is valid).
    • Example: In "Selections" sheet, list selected Fast moves in column A and Charge moves in column B.
  2. Dynamic Row Count:

    • Count the selected moves using COUNTA or similar.
    • Example: =COUNTA(A:A) for the count of Fast moves.

Helper Table with Dynamic Pairing

To automate combinations:

  1. Create a helper table with two dynamic columns:
    • First column: Repeat each Fast move for the count of Charge moves.
    • Second column: Cycle through Charge moves repeatedly to align with the Fast repeats.

Formulas for Pairing

Assume:

  1. First Column (Fast Moves):

    • Use:
      =INDEX(Selections.A$1:A$100, INT((ROW()-1)/COUNTA(Selections.B$1:B$100))+1)
    • This repeats each Fast move enough times to match all Charge moves.
  2. Second Column (Charge Moves):

    • Use:
      =INDEX(Selections.B$1:B$100, MOD(ROW()-1, COUNTA(Selections.B$1:B$100))+1)
    • This cycles through Charge moves.

Key Benefits


Final Note

With this setup, the helper table grows and shrinks based on the number of selected moves, ensuring full automation of the pairing process. All downstream calculations and results will update dynamically.