M: Name ten major internal
contradictions of the Bible
G: Critics often point to various
passages in the Bible that appear to present internal contradictions.
Here are ten examples that are frequently cited:
Creation Accounts (Genesis 1 vs. Genesis 2)
- Genesis 1: Humans are created last after all plants
and animals.
- Genesis 2: Man (Adam) is created first, followed by
plants, animals, and then woman (Eve).
The Order of Creation (Genesis 1:11-13, 1:20-23 vs.
Genesis 2:5-7, 2:19)
- Genesis 1: Plants are created on the third day and
birds on the fifth day.
- Genesis 2: Man is created before plants and
birds.
The Number of Animals on Noah's Ark (Genesis 6:19-20 vs.
Genesis 7:2-3)
- Genesis 6: Two of every kind of animal (male and
female).
- Genesis 7: Seven pairs of clean animals and birds,
and two of unclean animals.
The Length of Time in Egypt (Exodus 12:40 vs. Galatians
3:17)
- Exodus 12:40: Israelites were in Egypt for 430
years.
- Galatians 3:17: Paul implies the period from
Abraham to the Law (including the stay in Egypt) was 430 years.
Judas' Death (Matthew 27:5 vs. Acts 1:18)
- Matthew 27: Judas hangs himself.
- Acts 1: Judas falls headlong, his body bursts
open.
God's Nature (Exodus 33:20 vs. Genesis
32:30)
- Exodus 33:20: No one can see God and live.
- Genesis 32:30: Jacob claims to have seen God
face-to-face and survived.
The Genealogy of Jesus (Matthew 1 vs. Luke
3)
- Matthew 1: Lists 41 generations from Abraham to
Jesus.
- Luke 3: Lists 76 generations from Adam to
Jesus.
The Timing of Jesus' Crucifixion (Mark 15:25 vs. John
19:14)
- Mark 15: Jesus is crucified at the third hour (9
AM).
- John 19: Jesus is still before Pilate at the sixth
hour (noon).
Who Bought the Potter's Field (Matthew 27:6-7 vs. Acts
1:18-19)
- Matthew 27: Priests buy the field with the money
Judas returned.
- Acts 1: Judas buys the field himself.
Paul's Companions Hearing the Voice (Acts 9:7 vs. Acts
22:9)
- Acts 9:7: Paul's companions hear the voice but see
no one.
- Acts 22:9: Paul's companions see the light but do
not understand the voice.
These examples are often discussed in theological studies and debates
regarding biblical inerrancy and interpretation. Different traditions
and scholars offer various explanations and harmonizations for these
apparent contradictions.
M: Name ten contradictions of
philosophical weight, not of specific particular factual claims
G: Examining the Bible from a
philosophical perspective, certain themes and teachings can be seen as
presenting internal contradictions or tensions. Here are ten such
contradictions that are often discussed:
God’s Nature: Omnipotence vs.
Omnibenevolence
- Omnipotence: God is all-powerful (e.g., Matthew
19:26).
- Omnibenevolence: God is all-good (e.g., Psalm
145:9).
- Contradiction: The existence of evil and suffering
in the world raises questions about how an omnipotent and omnibenevolent
God can coexist with such realities.
Free Will vs. Predestination
- Free Will: Humans have the freedom to choose (e.g.,
Deuteronomy 30:19).
- Predestination: God has predetermined everything
(e.g., Romans 8:29-30).
- Contradiction: If God has predetermined all events,
it challenges the notion that humans have true free will.
God’s Immutability vs. Repentance
- Immutability: God does not change (e.g., Malachi
3:6).
- Repentance: God changes His mind or repents (e.g.,
Genesis 6:6, Exodus 32:14).
- Contradiction: An unchanging God changing His mind
presents a philosophical paradox.
Justice vs. Mercy
- Justice: God is just and demands justice (e.g.,
Isaiah 61:8).
- Mercy: God is merciful and forgives (e.g., Psalm
103:8).
- Contradiction: The balance between justice and
mercy can be philosophically challenging, as true justice seems to
preclude mercy and vice versa.
Faith vs. Works
- Faith: Salvation is through faith alone (e.g.,
Ephesians 2:8-9).
- Works: Faith without works is dead (e.g., James
2:26).
- Contradiction: The relationship between faith and
works in salvation presents a theological and philosophical
tension.
Universal Love vs. Exclusivity of Salvation
- Universal Love: God loves all people (e.g., John
3:16).
- Exclusivity of Salvation: Salvation is only through
Jesus (e.g., John 14:6).
- Contradiction: The idea of a universally loving God
who limits salvation to a specific group poses a philosophical
challenge.
God’s Sovereignty vs. Human Responsibility
- God’s Sovereignty: God is in control of everything
(e.g., Proverbs 16:9).
- Human Responsibility: Humans are responsible for
their actions (e.g., Ezekiel 18:20).
- Contradiction: The coexistence of God's complete
control and human moral responsibility is philosophically complex.
The Law vs. Grace
- The Law: The Old Testament emphasizes adherence to
the Law (e.g., Deuteronomy 6:25).
- Grace: The New Testament emphasizes salvation by
grace (e.g., Romans 6:14).
- Contradiction: The shift from a legalistic
framework to one of grace and forgiveness raises questions about
continuity and change in divine expectations.
Love for Enemies vs. Divine Judgment
- Love for Enemies: Jesus teaches to love enemies
(e.g., Matthew 5:44).
- Divine Judgment: God will judge and condemn the
wicked (e.g., Revelation 20:15).
- Contradiction: Balancing the command to love
enemies with the concept of divine retribution presents a philosophical
tension.
God’s Hiddenness vs. Desire for Relationship
- God’s Hiddenness: God is often perceived as hidden
or distant (e.g., Isaiah 45:15).
- Desire for Relationship: God seeks a personal
relationship with humans (e.g., James 4:8).
- Contradiction: The tension between God’s hiddenness
and the desire for an intimate relationship with humans raises questions
about divine accessibility and the nature of faith.
These philosophical contradictions are often explored in theological
and philosophical discussions, with various interpretations and
resolutions proposed by scholars, theologians, and religious
traditions.
M: Briefly, Decent substitute for
pollock in frying
G: A decent substitute for pollock
in frying is cod. Cod has a similar mild flavor and flaky texture,
making it an excellent alternative for fried dishes. Other suitable
substitutes include haddock, tilapia, or catfish, which also provide a
similar taste and consistency when fried.
M: What makes up tartar sauce
G: Tartar sauce is typically made
up of the following ingredients:
- Mayonnaise: The base of the sauce, providing a
creamy texture.
- Pickles or Relish: Chopped pickles or sweet relish
for tanginess and crunch.
- Capers: Optional, but they add a briny flavor.
- Lemon Juice: For acidity and freshness.
- Dill or Parsley: Fresh or dried herbs for
flavor.
- Mustard: Adds a bit of sharpness (optional).
- Onion or Shallot: Finely chopped, for extra flavor
(optional).
- Salt and Pepper: To taste.
These ingredients are mixed together to create a tangy, creamy sauce
commonly served with fried fish.